Rhodes Finishes His Story

Written By
Steven Donald
Updated
October 15, 2025
WrestleMania XL: Cody Rhodes triumphs

How often do we see a long storyline pay off in sports entertainment? At WrestleMania XL, we saw something special. It was a mix of corporate goals and emotional closure.

The return of the prodigal son marked the end of a 1317-day reign. It was the fourth longest in WWE history. This was more than just winning a title. It was about finishing a family legacy that spanned decades.

This moment is culturally significant. It’s like a mix of Shakespearean tragedy and American determination. A story of leaving to prove oneself, then coming back to achieve what a legendary father couldn’t.

The emotional peak was helped by icons like The Undertaker and John Cena. But the real magic was seeing a mother get the championship her husband always dreamed of.

Full Match Recap

WrestleMania 40 was like the Zapruder film. It needed analysis to see the whole picture. The main event was more than a wrestling match; it was a real-time myth.

The Bloodline Rules stipulation led to chaos, like a Shakespearean tragedy. Roman Reigns went down after multiple Cross Rhodes moves. Interference from superstars added depth to the epic conclusion.

A dramatic, high-contrast image of Cody Rhodes triumphantly celebrating his WrestleMania victory over Roman Reigns. In the foreground, Rhodes stands tall, fist raised in a powerful victory pose, his face etched with fierce determination. The middle ground captures the fallen Reigns, his defeated expression conveying the weight of the moment. Dimly lit crowd silhouettes fill the background, their roars and cheers palpable. The scene is bathed in warm, dramatic lighting, casting dynamic shadows and highlights that accentuate the raw emotion of the moment. Shot from a low angle, the image emphasizes the grandeur and significance of Rhodes' achievement on the biggest stage of them all.

Damian Priest made a perfect move. He used his Money in the Bank contract on Drew McIntyre at the worst time. CM Punk’s attack on McIntyre opened the door for Judgment Day’s first world champion.

This was more than a title change; it was a storytelling lesson. It set up a feud between McIntyre and Punk and made Priest a main event star.

The Bayley versus Iyo Sky match was a technical masterpiece, earning an A- grade. It showed the best of women’s wrestling, with crisp moves and emotional storytelling. The conclusion felt earned, not given.

The triple threat United States Championship match was a mess of glory. Logan Paul kept his title against Kevin Owens and Randy Orton. The match was absurdly entertaining, with RKOs and mascot costumes.

LA Knight’s win over AJ Styles showed that megastars can be made in one match. The right opponent and moment can cement a legacy.

In 2024 WWE, nothing happens alone. The Cody Rhodes victory wasn’t just the end of his story. It was the start of new chapters for everyone.

WrestleMania 40 showed wrestling at its best is like complex machinery. Every move, every interference, and every title change has an effect on the whole story.

The Rock & Cena Returns

WWE pulled out all the stops, using Roman Reigns as the ultimate challenge. They didn’t just send one hero. They called in the whole team.

The main event turned into a WWE version of a Marvel movie mashup. The Rock came in with a Rock Bottom, echoing through wrestling history. Then, John Cena showed up, hitting an Attitude Adjustment on Roman Reigns in a move that was both shocking and expected.

Roman Reigns, the Tribal Chief, stands tall in the center of the ring, surrounded by a gathering of legendary WWE superstars. In the foreground, John Cena and The Rock, two of the greatest icons in sports entertainment history, face off with Reigns, their eyes locked in a tense and intense standoff. The middle ground features other legendary figures, such as Hulk Hogan, Shawn Michaels, and The Undertaker, watching the confrontation unfold. The background is shrouded in a dramatic, almost cinematic lighting, casting long shadows and creating a sense of weight and importance to the moment. The scene exudes a palpable aura of power, history, and the ultimate clash of titans about to unfold.

The Undertaker’s return was more than just a nod to fans. It was a strategic move to balance The Rock’s power. His chokeslam was the perfect counter to The Bloodline’s dominance.

This was WWE showing off its cultural relevance. Each return was a moment of explosive drama and a necessary part of the story. It felt organic and satisfying, like getting the dream matchups we never knew we wanted.

When a villain is as strong as Roman Reigns, you need legends to make the victory feel right. You need the weight of wrestling history to make it feel earned.

The Bloodline’s reign needed a strong response. It wasn’t overdoing it; it was using the right amount of force. Roman Reigns was so powerful that only WWE’s greatest heroes could stop him.

This moment was special because it knew it was absurd yet played it seriously. We got to enjoy the nostalgia while also seeing the story move forward. WWE gave us what we wanted and what the story needed.

In the end, these returns made Cody Rhodes’ win feel both earned and epic. They also set up future stories. The legends didn’t overshadow him; they made him better by association.

WWE’s use of legends was genius. They didn’t use them as crutches but as powerful tools. With characters as big as these, why not use them to take down the biggest threats?

WWE Landscape After the Upset

Cody Rhodes now holds the WWE 2024 title, marking a big change. The Bloodline’s power has fallen, and a new era is starting. This could be WWE’s most exciting time in years.

Damian Priest’s cash-in on Raw adds intrigue, possibly making Judgment Day big players. Bayley’s win opens up new stories in the women’s division. And CM Punk and Drew McIntyre’s feud is waiting to ignite.

When Triple H, Nick Khan, and Bruce Prichard gave Rhodes the gold watch, it was a deep moment. It tied back to Dusty Rhodes’ past, showing a full circle. This moment was highlighted by the #WeWantCody movement that changed WrestleMania’s main event.

This WWE 2024 title win is special because it shows fan power can change stories. It’s a big shift where fans’ wishes helped shape the story. Now, the question is if WWE can keep this connection with fans after WrestleMania.